Baseball All-Time Awards and Honors
| Name | Association | Award | Division | Year |
| Brad Smock | GLVC | All-League Second Team | II | 1999 |
| Brain Bogs | GLVC | All-League Second Team | II | 2000 |
| Brandon Knowling | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | April 21, 2008 |
| Brandon Knowling | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | May 5, 2008 |
| Brandon Knowling | Summit League | All-League First Team | I | 2008 |
| Brandon Phelps | Summit League | Academic All-League | I | 2018 |
| Brandon Phelps | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | May 21, 2018 |
| Brandon Soat | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2015 |
| Brandon Soat | Summit League | All-Tournament Team | I | 2016 |
| Brandon Soat | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | Feb 23, 2015 |
| Brandon Soat | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | May 9, 2016 |
| Brandon Soat | Summit League | All-League First Team | I | 2016 |
| Brent Doty | Independent | Player of the Week | I | April 19, 2006 |
| Brock Logan | Collegiate Baseball | Freshman All-America | I | 2015 |
| Brock Logan | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2015 |
| Brock Logan | Summit League | All-Tournament Team | I | 2016 |
| Caleb Fenimore | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | March 25, 2013 |
| Caleb Fenimore | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2013 |
| Carter Deboe | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | March 12, 2012 |
| Carter DeBoe | Summit League | All-League First Team | I | 2014 |
| Carter Deboe | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | May 7, 2012 |
| Charles Weaver | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | April 2, 2012 |
| Chris Gottschall | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | April 20, 2009 |
| Clay Hathaway | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | April 22, 2013 |
| Clay Hathaway | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2013 |
| Evan Miller | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2015 |
| Evan Miller | Collegiate Baseball | Freshman All-America | I | 2015 |
| Evan Miller | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | April 27, 2015 |
| Evan VanSumeren | Summit League | All-Tournament Team | I | 2014 |
| Evan VanSumeren | Summit League | All-Tournament Team | I | 2016 |
| Garett Lake | Horizon League | All-Academic Team | I | 2021 |
| Garrett Mohler | Summit League | Academic All-League | I | 2019 |
| Greg Kaiser | CoSIDA | Academic All-America Third Team | I | 2015 |
| Greg Kaiser | CoSIDA | Academic All-District | I | 2015 |
| Greg Kaiser | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | March 24, 2014 |
| Greg Kaiser | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2015 |
| Greg Kaiser | Summit League | All-Tournament Team | I | 2016 |
| Greg Kaiser | Senior CLASS | Senior CLASS | I | 2016 |
| Greg Kaiser | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | March 17, 2014 |
| Greg Kaiser | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | April 18, 2016 |
| Greg Kaiser | Summit League | Academic All-League | I | 2014 |
| Greg Kaiser | Summit League | All-Tournament Team | I | 2015 |
| Greg Kaiser | Summit League | Academic All-League | I | 2015 |
| Greg Kaiser | Summit League | All-League First Team | I | 2016 |
| Greg Kaiser | Summit League | Academic All-League | I | 2016 |
| Jack Lang | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | Feb 17, 2020 |
| Jackson Boyce | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2016 |
| Jackson Boyce | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2017 |
| Jared Davis | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | April 28, 2008 |
| Jared Davis | Independent | Newcomer of the Week | I | April 17, 2007 |
| Jared Davis | Independent | Newcomer of the Year | I | 2007 |
| Jared Davis | Independent | All-League First Team | I | 2007 |
| Jared Davis | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2008 |
| Jason Kalber | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | April 15, 2013 |
| Jonathan Valenzuela-Reece | Summit League | All-Tournament Team | I | 2015 |
| Kendall Whitman | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | April 27, 2015 |
| Kendall Whitman | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2015 |
| Kevin Wirth | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | Feb 17, 2014 |
| Kristian Gayday | Summit League | All-Tournament Team | I | 2014 |
| Mark Carden | Independent | Newcomer of the Week | I | March 27, 2007 |
| Mark Carden | Independent | All-League Second Team | I | 2007 |
| Mark Vince | GLVC | All-League Second Team | II | 1994 |
| Markus Kalber | Summit League | Academic All-League | I | 2013 |
| Markus Kalber | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | Feb 18, 2013 |
| Mike Snyder | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | April 23, 2018 |
| Nick Opitz | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | May 16, 2011 |
| Rob Milledge | GLVC | All-League First Team | II | 1994 |
| Rob Milledge | GLVC | All-League Second Team | II | 1995 |
| Ryan Keena | Independent | All-League Second Team | I | 2005 |
| Ryan Steinbach | Independent | All-League Second Team | I | 2005 |
| Ryan Wells | Summit League | All-Tournament Team | I | 2015 |
| Ryan Wells | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | April 6, 2015 |
| Samuel Walker | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | March 28, 2011 |
| Sean Kirk | Independent | All-League Second Team | I | 2005 |
| Shane Trevino | Summit League | Player of the Week | I | Feb 16, 2015 |
| Shane Trevino | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2015 |
| Shane Trevino | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2016 |
| Shannon Baker | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2018 |
| Shaun VanDriessche | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2010 |
| Stacey Herrold | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | May 4, 2009 |
| Steve Danielak | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2012 |
| Steve Lowden | Summit League | All-League First Team | I | 2014 |
| Steve Lowden | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2013 |
| Terry Johnson | GLVC | All-League Second Team | II | 1997 |
| Travis Upp | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2018 |
| Trevor Storie | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | May 2, 2016 |
| Trevor Storie | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | May 23, 2016 |
| Trevor Storie | Summit League | All-League First Team | I | 2016 |
| Troy Dickerson | GLVC | All-League Team | II | 1986 |
| Tyler Fowler | Independent | All-Tournament Team | I | 2006 |
| Tyler Kissinger | Summit League | Pitcher of the Week | I | Feb 17, 2020 |
| Tyler Sheperd | Summit League | All-League Second Team | I | 2013 |
| Jacob Myer | Horizon League | Pitcher of the Week | I | April 12, 2022 |
| Ben Higgins | Horizon League | Batter of the Week | I | April 19, 2022 |
| Garett Lake | Horizon League | All-Academic Team | I | 2022 |
| Alex Evenson | Horizon League | All-Academic Team | I | 2022 |
| Jack Lang | Horizon League | All-League Second Team | I | 2022 |
| Cade Fitzpatrick | Horizon League | All-League Second Team | I | 2022 |
| Ben Higgins | Horizon League | All-League Second Team | I | 2023 |
| Braedon Blackford | Horizon League | All-League First Team | I | 2023 |
| Ben Higgins | Horizon League | All-Academic Team | I | 2023 |
| JD Deany | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2023 |
| Kevin Fee | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2023 |
| Dylan Stewart | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2023 |
| Ben Higgins | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2023 |
| Braedon Blackford | Horizon League | Batter of the Week | I | March 8, 2023 |
| Ben Higgins | Horizon League | Batter of the Week | I | April 4, 2023 |
| Kevin Fee | Horizon League | All-Academic Team | I | 2024 |
| Ben Higgins | Horizon League | All-Academic Team Honorable Mention | I | 2024 |
| Kevin Fee | Horizon League | All-League First Team | I | 2024 |
| Jacob Walker | Horizon League | All-League Second Team | I | 2024 |
| Carter Sabol | Horizon League | All-League Second Team | I | 2024 |
| Justin Osterhouse | Horizon League | All-League Second Team | I | 2024 |
| Justin Osterhouse | Horizon League | All-Freshman Team | I | 2024 |
| Jacob Walker | Horizon League | Sportsmanship Award | I | 2024 |
| Kevin Fee | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2024 |
| Owen Willard | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2024 |
| Jacob Walker | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2024 |
| Mac Ayres | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2024 |
| Justin Osterhouse | Horizon League | Batter of the Week | I | March 13, 2024 |
| Kevin Fee | Horizon League | Pitcher of the Week | I | March 13, 2024 |
| Carter Sabol | Horizon League | Pitcher of the Week | I | April 9, 2024 |
| Justin Osterhouse | Horizon League | Batter of the Week | I | April 1, 2025 |
| Zane Danielson | Horizon League | Pitcher of the Week | I | April 1, 2025 |
| Cole Newell | Horizon League | Pitcher of the Week | I | May 6, 2025 |
| Justin Osterhouse | Horizon League | All-Academic Team | I | 2025 |
| Brooks Sailors | Horizon League | All-Academic Team | I | 2025 |
| Dylan Chargo | Horizon League | All-Academic Team Honorable Mention | I | 2025 |
| Justin Osterhouse | Horizon League | Batter of the Week | I | May 19, 2025 |
| Justin Osterhouse | Horizon League | Pitcher of the Week | I | May 19, 2025 |
| Justin Osterhouse | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2025 |
| Carson Caudill | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2025 |
| Cole Newell | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2025 |
| Gavin Walters | CSC (previously CoSIDA) | Academic All-District | I | 2025 |
| Camden Karczewski | Horizon League | All-League First Team | I | 2025 |
| Justin Osterhouse | Horizon League | All-League Second Team | I | 2025 |
| Trent Murphy | Horizon League | All-Freshman Team | I | 2025 |
| Brooks Sailors | Horizon League | Sportsmanship Award | I | 2025 |
